I think we all have a degree of understanding of what your arguments are. 

My question is, why let a thread be consumed with the same restating on both sides when the same information has already been posted? This is the internet, the need for an immediate response doesn't actually exist, so why not wait to let the third party that actually matters, the GM, respond. Cause when a debate degenerates into personal attacks it stops being a debate of any value. 

In the meantime, I'm sure there's more productive uses of everyone's time. You can get back to yelling at each other when the GM returns and has laid forth his views.