Well I'll put a post up tonight and see how it goes.  I'm still definitely learning as a Gm and I realized 2 things.

1. Ancient Dragon Had only been in the guild a month, and this was their first roleplay.  Shouldn't leave a roleplay's future solely dependent on their response.

2. I probably should have waited a bit longer before I did that to anyone.  I know early on people tend to start and drop quickly.

EDIT: Fell asleep.  Hopefully today instead