[quote=@Ellri]
We think we deviated a bit above, but some of the mistakes weren't easily quantified into a single sentence.
[/quote]

Nah, it's all good. I can see some points where I have made, or seen those mistakes in the past with RPs I've been in. One point I do completely understand is players making unexpected choices or being in unexpected situations. It's a hard one as it requires a lot of planning and understanding in the direction you want to go but everything can be turned upside down when someone makes an innocent post that you didn't initially predict. It's worse when you look back and think, "Damn, should have seen that coming", but on the flip side those sort of twists are what makes this Roleplaying and simply not a linear storyline.

Your comment on Time is one that I COMPLETELY agree with. Even without thinking some people begin to advance the time and then you have the situation where two people meet and somehow one is still in morning yet the other is in the afternoon, and how does it take 10 hours to make a cup of tea or 20min to go around the world, find a relic, fight off an army, and return back to your original destination in time to hear the end of that conversation that was started when you left.

They're not necessarily game killers but if you break the immersion people will be startled and start questioning the quality of the RP they entered.