[quote=@Willy Vereb]
<Snipped quote by Cyclone>I liked your nation a lot but I think a HRE style nation could be similarly fun if not moreso. You can add Austrian/Habsburg elements combined with Prussians and WW1 Germans, too. 
Does it mean you'd rather play in an Earth-style map? Asking since the current opinion is very much between that or the world of Ace Combat.
[/quote]

Thanks for the feedback. As in for your question, I remain opposed to an Earth map.

[quote]Also the idea that it'd feel wrong to have dwarves or fantasy elements on Earth is strange when they originated straight from here. Myths telling these races were putting them in our world.[/quote]

This logic starts to crumble when you extend it to say that Jedi, the Borg, giant green slimeball aliens, the blue people from Avatar, and anything else that has ever been conceived would fit in great on an Earth setting, just because humans imagined them.

Look, when you say elves I think of Lord of the Rings or World of Warcraft, not Earth. All I'm saying is that I'd find an Earth setting really strange in this context and I don't think I'm the only one.

Then there's the part where I dislike excessive parralelism to real life in a story. While the theme of an altered history with our fantasy nations instead of real ones might be appealing to some, it isn't to me and I don't think that's what was intended as the genre for this.