Then she suddenly vomitted blood. So much blood that the blood spilled out of the shower after filling it entirely with blood. I thought I was going to drown in blood when all of a sudden it morphed together into the shape of a blood pony.

"I am Bloodie Pie, and I shall make a pie with your blood!" The pony screeched at me in a gurgling, bloody sound. The other pony only laughed, showing me her blood soaked teeth.

((We failed the challenge long ago for this story, just in the off chance you guys didn't notice. We can continue and not worrying about finishing our real creepy pasta in time, whatever floats our boat))