Huh I like him too, I really think either of them would work really. It kind of depends on how you see his personality. I don't really know what you have in mind for him. 

The first picture kinda looks like he would be proper and snooty. The second one looks more like he would be proper too but more likely to let people bend the rules a little and a little more laid back. Though that's just what I see from the pictures.