I know I'm not really around that much so my opinion is probably worthless, but I would go for the reboot option. This was my first RP and I feel that my posts have been rather sub-standard I'm hopefully improving and a fresh start would allow me to iron out a few kinks in Ionathan personality and character. It would also allow anyone to tweak their character if they felt that they would prefer to be something else. 

But above all, I would like to thank everyone in this RP for putting up with a newbie like me with my bad posts and horrible grammar mistakes. I wish you all the best of luck in your future endeavours.