Finally, a roleplay that calls out to my soul. 

Name: Sha'Quan
Bread: Cardboard
Cheese: Shredded Orange & Yellow Crayon
Personality: Sha'Quan is the product of a 1st Grader's arts and crafts session. He made his favorite food, a grilled cheese, but since first graders aren't responsible enough to make an actual grilled cheese (nor are there adequate materials in the art room), Sha'Quan was made from the sturdiest cardboard and [b]Real Crayons™.[/b] Since he's not a real grilled cheese, Sha'Quan gets really depressed sometimes, and he gets even more depressed since he has no tear ducts to adequately cry.  
Powers/ Abilities: Can turn into two pieces of cardboard and shredded crayon if someone knocks him over