I personally enjoyed both. I did love the Books more so because of the quips in there you can only get in the books due to being inside Bella's head. The movies aren't the best, but I still found them mildly enjoyable. But then again, most things don't irritate me. Except parody movies. And quite a bit of 'comedy' And I just enjoy loving things everyone loves to hate. Cuz fuck norms. XD I <3 Twilight Edit: and I also liked Eragon the movie xD