I'm just going to post this, which is what I sent Demon other than the part that was just part of our convo and edited because I mistyped a few things

 I thought my logic was straight forward enough I mean who can heal from an arrow in the eye, shoulder, and ear in 10 minutes.I mean an arrow in the ear could probably heal within 45 mins. In the shoulder I'd say 12-24 hours due to the muscles and ligaments in the shoulder area being torn by it. But for an eye! The arrow could have possibly killed him because of the brain being right there ya know. To heal from a wound to the eye would take as long as a broken bone would. If he's going to have his character heal that quickly then my character would have healed in half that time.