[@Cruallassar]
If you minus the nearly indestructible shield and the fact he doesn't have his speed, experience, reflexes, durability and guns.
Not even remotely close to captain america, two very different people with very different abilities.
edit: also isn't really trained in hand to hand combat, remove his sword and he can hit you hard but not with any great technique (unless we're going with jabs and upper-cut. That's about it XD, maybe also slinging people over his shoulders).
Really his only decent trait is his strength, his reflexes can't really match Magna's so that's why he's been avoiding close-quarter combat. Also isn't Magna afraid of bright light? Why is he running around a fire? XD