[quote=@VitaVitaAR]I'm not sure how stuff like that is too silly for a setting with literal space magic.[/quote]

I don't think space magic is silly. On the contrary, I think it's kinda cool. Fighting spaceships with enormous swords is, however, extremely silly-sounding. Punching satellites is, too.

[quote=@Rin]
I'm starting to get the feeling that half of us want something grim and gritty, whilst the other half want something that's over the top and filled with magic robots.  Might be a little tricky to mesh this together, but we'll see how things turn out I guess. ^^;
[/quote]

I'm not so much into grim and dark as I am in having a nice conflict and avoiding sillyness.