I could step in and make a judgement if needed (MelonHead and Chimera had already made me do that twice), but I'm not sure it's really necessary here?  It looks like you two are just making sure things are clear, and while there have been some different points brought up, there's been no disagreement so far.  So I see no reason not to just get on with posting... some details may not be precisely worked out, but they may not need to be.

IDK.  If you two really would rather I step in, I can, but I find it's usually best when players resolve things themselves.