[quote=@RainbowReindeer] im sorry but this didn't make sense to me. so if mudheart didn't go anywhere, then whom did the warriors trust to 'go alone'? The deputy? [/quote] [quote=@Shurikai] I think Violet means that Amberstar is at Starfall with Mudheart to receive her title and nine lives. Since Mudheart "was stuck" being medi apprentice, he wasn't "chosen" to be medicine cat so he doesn't have dreams..? [/quote] Actually, I meant the Deputy that we do not have. I gave him a reason to not be there. Mudheart hadn't had a prophetic dream from Starclan saying they needed this unnamed deputy. Therefore, he was stuck at camp. Oh and I'm so taking Nightkit btdubs. Kind of funny actually. Cuz the only other cat without an apprentice that I don't own in that clan is Briartorn XD