Bane looked over at Serena as she used the water to clean the wound, Bilbo gasping in pain. She smiled and said "You are quite brave, master hobbit...the fact you took the wound and still tried to defend your comrades, very noble of you..." Bilbo flinched as she pulled a small bottle from her bag and started to put herbs and liquids into the wound. "This will help with the pain and keep it clean..." She looked at Thorin, glaring at him. "How could you travel without a healer! Its risky where you are heading, even more right now, and you don't bother to at least bring supplies in case one of your company is hurt? What kind of..." Bane suddenly covered her mouth, sighing. 

"Please forgive my lady...she's doesn't take lightly when others are hurt like this..." Gandalf was watching her silently, thinking. She slapped Bane's hand and said "I'm just saying...its unwise and selfish..." She turned back to Bilbo, starting to wrap the wound with Bane's ripped shirt.