[quote=@Ammokkx] I'm not. There's a reason I outright rejected a certain card, it was more like a novel rather than anything else. Also, the anime-only monster that was a Rank 13 was a thing. Please tell me how you're going to summon that with actual Xyz materials. Or Dark Synchros, those were pretty wonky too. I know the idea behind Xyz, but if we're really going down that path, then there's a clear divide between specifics and splashable materials. There's a ton of generic rank 4's, but then some require actual named cards (hello fiend eagle). I'd consider this just another way of specifying what type of monster you need. I mean, you could use those very same monsters to Xyz Summon Exciton Knight and Castel. Hardly fair imo. [/quote] Ancient Dragon, Greed Quasar, Hermit of Prophecy, etc. And those anime-only cards remained anime-only for a reason. I honestly don't see how they relate to what we're discussing since we are talking about the game as we are trying to play completely unscripted. And yes, some Xyz Monsters require specific named materials, but those materials have the same requirements, which is the point I'm trying to make. It's fine if it's just specifying the materials required, I'm saying that we should follow precedence and make those requirements the same. And yeah, Exciton and Castel are super splashable and versatile Xyz Monsters, but I'm not discussing that the card is OP, I'm saying that it's just not how Xyz Monsters work.