[quote=@DarkwolfX37]
<Snipped quote by Host>

Mental link bro. Or alts. Or we had similar subconscious information picked up on. 
[/quote]

Probably the last option. I think that the dream generated a variable placeholder that was similar enough to the profile pic and our subconscious minds latched onto that image and filled it into the memories.

[quote=@Multifarious]
<Snipped quote by Host>

I do remember you describing your feelings about it to me, though.
[/quote]

The worst part was all of it. I also licked my phone.