For Arthur, though twas not easy.

Age: Older and Wiser (5)
Sexuality: Straight (3)
Love Interest: Temporary?? (4)
Role: Mentor (5)
Race: White (1)
Gender: Male (3)
Aesthetics: "Average" (3)
Personality: (I frankly have no idea what to put here. I'll just say 3, if anyone feels like arguing that I'm willing to listen)
Flaws: Smartass (4)
Virtues: Determinator (2)
Species: Human (3)
Occupation: Teacher (2)
Prognosis: You Shall Not Pass (4)
Health: Only A Flesh Wound (2)

Which totals... 46, out of a total 75, where bigger number is more dead. Well if you think this little number game is enough to kill Arthur then you'll have to try harder TVtropes!