[quote=@BBeast]
<Snipped quote by Muttonhawk>

Depends. If you want to make a bona fide element, one which would show up on the periodic table, which is made from a single type of atom of neutrons, protons and electrons, that would require rewriting the Laws of Physics, while carefully avoiding messing up the existing elements, a task of nigh impossible difficulty. I'd bet even Logos would struggle with such a task.

If you are content with anything other than a pure atomic element, then there would be no trouble at all.
[/quote]

Nigh impossible? So you're saying it could be done?

More seriously, unless subatomic physics are going to be a fulcrum for this RP's storytelling, I do not see the issue with making an element and just saying "magic did it". There's no use in sweating the small stuff if a new material gets to be made.

Edit: I'll remind that this wasn't my idea, so it could go either way.