[quote=@Rin]
[@malmshodes]Can't speak for other people, but... You end up with a big, impenetrable wall of text which is usually just a big mess and also ends up destroying the individual voices of the writers to create some homogenous mush that's generally just not that fun to read.

I mean I have other problems with collabs, but those are my main ones.

As for the "power play" thing, I honestly think it completely removes the reactionary element of roleplaying, which wouldn't be so bad a thing [i]if the reactionary element wasn't one of the core elements of roleplaying.[/i]
[/quote]

I'm not sure about destroying the individuality since from what I gather collaboration posts are really similar to regular rp replying, as in its one after another, but then they share the same post.  So I can see how the size would be an issue, since their multiple rounds of posting all on a single space.  
Maybe the problem could be solved if instead of collaborating between post, combatants relied on the "mentioning" thing?  Again, just my two cents.  Not trying to step on any toes.  I just really want to see another One piece rp succeed!

I can't really say anything for the power play part since it seems like that would be entirely based on feeling and as I haven't tried it yet......  It would be like saying I do/don't like apples based on the shape.