Yo!

Issues, issues. Everything's really already stated in the OOC, I'll try and summarize my half of it, so you don't have to rummage through that hot greasy mess.

Divinity is forfeiting the fight, which would normally count as a loss; we have Innue as our judge, but Melon decided to drag you in to decide whether the fight should count as ranked or not. Personally I don't see why it shouldn't, me and Divinity initially agreed that it would, and though we had some disputes about each others profiles, we came to conclusions about those very early on in to the bout. There's definitely enough fighting and damage dished out to count as a real match. I think Melon's big case about how it shouldn't count as a ranked fight, stems from the fact we didn't flesh out every single little detail about the rules before our fight, and because we argued so much. (But he argues with everyone, too. I'm sure he has some argument radar built in to him.) I can see a wager chip in the rules idea, not the arguing one, but I figured that requesting a judge works the same way as setting up rules. This whole T1 Eden Era really isn't advertised as the default, not enough to be commonly known by everyone! Plus it needs to be revamped in order to properly include characters like mine, who rely on preparing multiple things at once mid-battle; fleshing out how Myron's skillset might work in pure T1EA turned in to an argument that ultimately resulted in Divinity's decision to bow out. On a side note, to try and defeat this whole rule dilemma, if T1EA was applied 100% to the fight, I still wouldn't have broken any rules... mainly because T1EA has some pretty commonplace guidelines that are agreed upon in an unspoken manner by combat veterans.

So here we are!