[@RumikoOhara]Because they played out the class and you do NOT have to play out the classes. They should only be relevant if some sort of important plot information or anything plot related is being done. That is why they fail. That may just be a common thing on this site but school RPs are successful everywhere else. In the end, RPs only fail when the writers just lose inspiration, go AWOl, or simply move on. RPs are meant to be enjoyed while they last.

As for the toon powers thing, I also disagree. I've seen comedy characters workout to everyone's enjoyment. The silliness aspect would have just been to make for a silly character, but I plan to make her serious. I'm not at a computer so I couldn't give you an example of what I mean by Faust silliness.

I can't decide to make her Domino-like or a Domino/Punisher type. :)