Lies... I think the idea of just keeping it ambiguous and mostly up to the person who killed the monster seems best. You guys might be able to find some ok armor, maybe a helm or boots, a dagger but nothing magical or unique. As for gold, just don't go overboard and be like "well I killed four squirrels let me just have 200k gp. Why not?" I trust none of you will be like that, I think everyone here has that maturity level where you understand if you don't set things up for your character to aim towards then its gonna be boring having him already finished.

Also some people haven't posted in a few days and seem to be falling behind, should we wait or after 4 days count them as like.. inactive >_> I don't wanna be a jerk but stopping the train for a few passengers just ruins everything..