[quote=@AtomicNut]
Puella Magi Madoka Magika
[/quote]

...As much as I liked the original series, it kind of got knocked off my top five due to several... [i]Issues[/i] I have with both the fanbase and the fact that I believe it should've stayed as a stand alone thing and never franchised off into all those spinoffs (which for the most part are pretty bad).

It kind of gets to the point that I kind of unfairly assume that anyone who says that it's their favourite magical girl anime... Well, I usually assume that it's also the [i]only[/i] magical girl anime they've seen. ^^;

...Still probably number six though if we only count the original series and disregard all the spinoffs and whatnot but hey.