So let me get this straight. You want to boot what amounts to more than half of the active playerbase, with the reason being having badwrongfun together in an otherwise dry scenario that gives no incentive to do anything with the players currently nor read any damn posts outside of your own due to the solitary nature of the aforementioned scenario. Just cuz one guy is desperate to be a GM and is doing constant concern whining. 

That's dumb and counterproductive.