Geoffrey. There was always something off about him. Always sneaking around and smirking whenever the Captain passed. Sebastian never liked him but he did good work with the sails so he never had a reason to kick him off. He nodded tersely. He could see the hate tearing him apart for breaking Pirate code. But if Sebastian had learned something in all his years it was that sometimes, you had to snitch if it meant saving your life. Elijah would forgive himself eventually. He touched his wife's hand before he turned and left Elijah with his regret. 

Josephine put her hand on Elijah's shoulder, giving him a reassuring smile. He always worked to fit in with the pirate crew and lived by all their rules. She could see the toll that breaking the rule of snitching was taking on him. He just wasn't having a good day and she wanted to hug him.