[@Bright_Ops]
Ehhhhhhhhh

Cat and maybe a rat, or perhaps some other large rodent. But a cat/cat implies it's even. I think once both parties are aware of the others intentions a witch has a much larger repertoire of things they can do to prepare. 
They can do everything the human can do but more.

So far we have only seen/dealt with a witches natural 'powers' but I still believe they can all cast spells/curses, scry, do rituals and sacrifices.
(Maybe even a little voodoo, I wouldn't let them have any hair just to be on the safe side.)

I still reckon if you chose hunter you have deliberately chosen the underdog.
Only wise hunters live long enough to become old.


Look I could be wrong, it's not my game, and it also depends on the witch in particular. But that's how I would play it.