Maggie had her hazel eyes trained on him, but was occasionally flicking them back to the plane ticket stub, when he spoke about Shaggy having a change to revisit something on his own violation. Even as Nate was voicing his own opinion, her thoughts concluded that Shaggy still shouldn't be holding onto such a trinket. It was completely unlike him. Looking at the date, it was recent; a not-too-long-ago indication. Three months ago on the current year, implying that the stub was new. The gang has been missing for two months; why would they go back to the place they were at years before? The timing just wasn't right. 

The question was hovering within Maggie's mind for a while. She was flipping it around in her hand, her flashlight's beam trained on it, as if looking for another indication on it that she missed. Noticing that Nate has left, she hurried herself to catch him in Fred's room (which was [i]way[/i] cleaner than her brother's own). Pointing her flashlight on the mirror, the word written made it as if her mind was blown. Maggie heard about the prison break, but this couldn't be him, could it? "Missing gang? Spooky Island? Prison break?", she asked rhetorically, adding to his statement. "Like, Zoinks", she softly spoke, looking at him with wide eyes. "We got a mystery on our hands. At Spooky Island".