[@Deos Morran]

While he may have alleviated her concerns about him being under the influence of devilish magic, He did not agree to have Shai gone by the afternoon.

which means he's willingly letting a potentially dangerous creature stay at his home, and she has no plausible deniability in regards to her whereabouts.

So I am unsure. It could really go either way.

[s]leaning towards burning the heretic[/s]