[@Deos Morran]

...I was gonna post a long winded explanation of Phoebes thoughts, but I'll do that in the post instead when I get around to it.

TL;DR version, Phoebe basically thinks Shai is crafting all of this in an attempt to once again, garner sympathy and protect herself via a sympathetic hunter, someone Phoebe should be getting along with/comrades with.

It'll probably make more sense in the post whenever I get it up. (miiight not be tonight)

If not, just chalk it up to religious fervor and everyone of the inquisitors being a pyromaniac.