Yes. Personally I'm kind of leaning more towards the city one, too. I think that it'd just work better, too. 

The first idea, the one with the small kind of town, it [i] could [/i] work... But, (I'm not meaning to be rude/offensive in any way) I feel that the way that setting seems, the role play may not be as eventful as the city one. 

Oh and I have two quick questions about characters. 1) Can we have more than one character, or would that not work? 2) (I suppose this is more of a question about the site then the role play) Character skellys: Will they be posted here or somewhere else? Like on a different thread or something? 
.