[quote=@Vilageidiotx]Whereas I understand where you guys are coming from, a face to face book club involves more personal investment than what we would do here, and as a result too much controversy is more likely to cause this project to fracture. 

Perhaps a veto with the caveat that the pro-thatbook side having the opportunity to plead the case of their book would be a workable solution?
[/quote]
I’ve been in a lot of online discussion groups that have functioned as clubs, so I don’t think they operate too different as offline. But I don’t mean to argue your point. My perspective is that a veto systems at all (this includes caveats) would be counterproductive and a system that works against an open forum of discussion is one that I am not at all interested in volunteering my time to.