If what Ryo says is true and that this is a trap, there's probs more hiding around here. We're in no shape to go throwing ourselves into danger so we should just focus on capturing one person and gtfo.

IC however, Orchid would definitely favor attacking them now. They're done looting and now they're just destroying the place, so there isn't anything left to save. Kill em all and try to leave a smart looking one alive for questioning. Then toss them into the fire. As for tactics, I'd say someone distracts them while the rest of us charge out and kill em in one blow.