[@Atroposer]Well his wife and kids would know, but he wouldn't advertise it to others, as he doesn't want to be dragged into that world.  Also, Zeus will probably still not like him, so he doesn't want to risk upsetting him.

I guess I'll have him pretend to be a witch by a different name, and the characters wouldn't know who he is.  The gods might be able to recognize him if they meet him, though, even in human form.