[quote=@Antarctic Termite]
[@Lmpkio] I know, but what makes Smudgie dear dark to him? She's a good kid, just with some unusual values.
[/quote]

I suppose its based off the action she was taking at the moment and probably might tampered with his first impressions. I mean, its not ALWAYS perfect. 

(Alternatively I could just check Smudgies profile again and try to change it, buuuuuuuuuuuut its too late to change things now at the moment).

Edit: And yes, past mistakes also make that up. He won't know what it committed, but he knows you have sinned more or less basically lol