not bad ideas, [@JBRam2002]. As an added thought to that... If the mentors are being judged by others as well as helping the newbies, there should be a system in place for dealing with "bad" mentors. Dealing with those who prove they are unsuitable for mentoring anyone. Simplest we can think of there is for the staff to have a tool in place for disabling someone's ability to use the mentor tag. naturally, we hope such a system would be utterly without use, but the guild is (mostly) populated by humans, and humans are fallible. We don't really feel someone should be banned from the guild entirely for just being poor at teaching newbies the ropes. (but of course, extreme cases will demand extreme measures.)