[@Bishop]

I'm going to try to sum that up in fewer words to ensure that I understand your point correctly, so correct me if I'm wrong. You're essentially saying that because God knows the choices we're going to make ahead of time, we don't have the free will to make the decisions because he already knows the answer. But the problem with that argument is that it implies that knowledge of the future impedes our ability to make choices with free will. Consider it this way: If I'm talking to someone I know well, I know they're not going to take out a gun and shoot themselves (extreme example, but it works). Does the fact that I know they won't do that preventing them from doing so? No, they totally have the free will to do that if they want, but because I know them, I know how they will behave. My knowledge of what the future will be doesn't impact the self-contained structure of a situation. There's also another concept that being in every place at every time means that "knowing the future" becomes kind of irrelevant because forever is the present for God. I don't really have a strong opinion on this concept, but it's there.

The problem with that argument is that it assumes the good and the bad are treated equally by God. They're not.