Underrated: Battleborn

Man, I actually had a ton of fun with this game, but alas it had to come out I think a week before Overwatch. Mind you, Battleborn is a different game, but they both look like class-based shooters from a distance. Not to take anything away from Overwatch, as that game is also fantastic, but Battleborn was far better than it got credit for.

Overrated: Every TellTale Game Ever

Okay this isn't exactly fair, and I know that. Sure, they have great stories, but the games are so formulaic at this point. You can see where the decisions you make don't honestly matter later on, or worse, you can see the game pause for a split second and load previous decisions just to show you how much your "options mattered". They are good, but I just feel like the engine has been so overdone at this point that they really need to re-work it. But they won't because they can crank out games incredibly fast because the engine will not ever change.