Underrated:  [b]Spec Ops: The Line[/b]

This game will fuck you up.  What starts as an unremarkable and basic 3rd person shooter devolves into a downward spiral of atrocities against humanity before you know it; each misstep and calamitous act quickly writing itself off as "he did it", and so the game continues.  The farther you get the crazier it gets, and you begin to realize how fucked up the main character really is, until it finally comes to the end and every single thing that you did is deconstructed and thrown in your face, almost as if the game is fully aware of your existence as a player and is telling you you did all of this.  It's definitely a very self-aware game that has a very linear path with a couple of moral choices here and there that have absolutely fuck-all effect on the final outcome; as if it's trying to tell you that these isolated acts of goodness don't begin to compare to everything else you've done.  It's only after the damage is done that your choices have any effect on the outcome.  The gameplay is as unremarkable as ever, but the storyline is one for the books.

Overrated:  [b]Battlefield 1[/b]

Let's be honest, the Battlefield franchise is starting to suffer from the same cookie-cutter fuckery that Call of Duty is (thank you [@Dark Wind] for that particular turn of phrase, lol).  Arguably, it has been since Battlefield 4.  I mean come on, it was basically the same as Battlefield 3, but with re-modeled and re-skinned vehicles and weapons, and some different maps.  BF1 isn't too different, and despite the fact that it takes place in World War 1, there's a lot of pretty exotic weapons with some attachments that were pretty exotic for the time.  At least there's nothing that could be called an anachronism in BF3 or 4, but for fuck's sake, reflex sights in the early 1900s?  I mean, it's not truly an anachronism, but they weren't exactly fucking commonplace either.  Like, shit, BF3 and 4 didn't have attachments that aren't already in mainstream production.  Plus it plays very much like the two prior Battlefield games, showing a lack of innovation which I solely blame on EA.  Fuck EA!