Just finished reading everything. You've made a lot of good arguments and I have to agree they are better than "this is what means to play-by-post RPing means" arguments that I received from my friend.

I want to state that I don't do that. I like reading whatever other people wrote 'cause it's fun, it makes me become a better writer/reader etc. The discussion is purely hypothetical, for me at least.

Anyway. Thank you for taking time answering :)