[quote=@Garattee] I dont mean to be that guy, but wasn't this game very highly praised? [/quote] Only on the internet and even then only among a niche crowd. It wasn't until the HD Re-release a couple years ago that people talked about it in some capacity other than pointing to it as an example of a game with a female protagonist and it wasn't until Ubisoft flat out lied and said "Nah we ain't showing BGE 2" that it re-entered the minds of people. It was reviewed well critically but was a commercial disaster. But that said, critically praised games can still be underrated since I'm assuming the metric isn't necessarily 'games critics didn't like but you did' since I mean like...Titanfall 2 and Final Fantasy 6 were mentioned in the topic.