I'm just going to offer my two cents and a couple of possible solutions on some of the points you made.

[quote] Law require all fake weapons have an orange tip or light green tip. [/quote]

I'm pretty sure the whole transferring wounds onto people thing isn't exactly legal either. He could either have removed the tip or painted the whole thing black.

[quote] This could describe just about anyone. Either you'll need a photo or add more to this description because I am not getting a very clear view of who he is. [/quote]

Yeah, he made me draw a picture for mine, but I have to agree that it's quite vague.

[quote] You failed to mention Rogue X in your history. [/quote]

I didn't either. Should I have?