As everything I could say has already been said, and oft times more eloquently/with far less salt, I will simply put in my two cents to say that I also believe that moderation on the Guild has been inconsistent at best, and would rather the team work [i]with[/i] the community rather than hide away in their private chatlogs and devise "solutions" [i]for[/i] the community without consultation.

I add my voice to this discussion so this whole thing has less of a chance to be blown under the rug as just something a "vocal minority" came up with. Accusing the grieved parties of vocal minority status is a common way to stifle discourse and attempt to discredit others in the eyes of third-party observers, and I'd hate to think the moderation staff, or even other regular users would stoop to such a low tactic.