I mean, that is your purview but I happen to think it is utterly and completely wrong with no foresight on the greater issue. But you’re welcome to believe that it’s irrelevant as I am to believe it is relevant – RPG does not exist in a vacuum and thus all the information needs to be accounted for. Yours or my opinion is objectively irrelevant though. It only matters what conclusion Sherlock comes to in the case of its validity.