Viva Piñata

A VERY strange, slighty experimental "gardening" game that was based off of a saturday morning cartoon, it had all the signs of a terrible game. That was until you actually played it and realized how insanely polished it was, how unique the visuals were and how there really wasn't anything else on the market close to it. 

Game reviewers gave it mediocre scores due to it "not having a clear demographic" which doesn't make sense imo and to this day it still is under the radar.