[quote=@Fabricant451]

This is sounding more like your issues with the game rather than the community as a whole.
[/quote]

I mean they sound like my issues because they are my issues, but just like your complaints about various games, I'm not the only one who holds these views.

I REALLY dont want to bring subjectivity here, but if a game has a large disconnect between critics and fanbase then there is a case for the game being both overrated and underrated depending on who you talk to.

Fallout 4 is a good game, its an open world FPS action game with some lighter RPG elements, but considering how different it is to past installments, you can see why some of the fanbase don't like it. I personally wouldn't have given it a 10/10 but trying to find a positive conversation about the game on the interwebs is like trying to find a good episode of the walking dead.  I can see how someone might sit through a snobby 2 hour long 'critique' video of Fallout 4 that absolutely shits down its throat, only to play the game and have quite a lot of fun.

I dont personally think sales are relevant, people who buy games like Madden, Fifa, COD probably know their games aren't very good but that's just what they like passing the time with.