I dislike the romance in the two ideas, I feel like you want to go for a love triangle and turn this into some soppy romance which I really hate the idea of. I'm a big fan of the warrior's series though and I'd like it if this rp focused more on the politics of it. not two cats falling in love and the world revolving around it. though this is your rp and if you want to go for a romance that's ok, but I'd be interested if it was more warrior cats instead of lover cats.

I like the second idea though!. though I have a suggestion for it, could the mate be the leader of another clan?, this way it adds a more political side to it as the marriage will cause a alliance between the two clans, thus turning the two clans into a superpower. but it can be ruined by the daughter running off with the rogue. [@Scott Silverado]