Alot of them die in the fight pits while trying to prove themselves.

Seriously though, I think the Guild is fine. It's been around for yonks and it'll keep going. Lots of RPs cropping up all the time, lots of people to talk to, an active discord, ect. It's not perfect by a long shot but it's got alot going for it.

However I will say that I think alot of new people struggle finding there way around to start with, how to get a RP going here, ect. Maybe a buddy system would help.