[quote=@POOHEAD189]
I have three different stories I could be writing for...and I don't...know...which. 
[/quote]

Just do all of them, man. I have at least four stories and I'm compiling them into a novel of sorts.

https://nanowrimo.org/participants/antarctic-termite/novels/into-the-dust-descend

We got some paranormal modern comedy stuff, some flat sci-fi, a modern fantasy (horror?) teen story, and a high fantasy plot. Currently doing the sci-fi city of filth prompt for one chapter, then I'll move back to the narrator and start a chapter of steelsmith high fantasy probably.

[quote=@Tybalt Capulet]
Yo, critique my synopsis, fam.

A Privateer ship wrecks on the coast of an undiscovered land. On these foreign shores, the sailors must hold out against the forces of nature, the mysterious, inhuman natives, and perhaps most frighteningly, the youthful incompetence of their leader.
[/quote]

Are you doing some paranormal alt-history stuff or did you make up your own setting? It sounds dandy.