[@Blackstripe]
The metaphysical ramifications of having more than one of an idea that encompasses all things that exist, have existed, or will ever exist aside, even the DC multiverse doesn't consistently have analogues to those people. In fact, even within the post-Flashpoint Orrery of Worlds, the only multiversal constant is The Atom for reasons nobody entirely understands. It stands to reason that a separate multiverse wouldn't have any analogues to DC stuff except by pure coincidence, right? So if we go by those rules then, for example, Lady Arcana would just be a version of Lady Arcana that superficially resembles Captain Marvel, rather than the other way around, right?

So why are you centering this on DC when you've got a setting all your own right there in the opening post?

I wouldn't say it's a [i]bad[/i] setting, all told. If you just had a little confidence in what you could do this could easily stand on it's own. All you'd have to do is drop those weird forced references to "Earth-1" because, I'll be straight with you, it's very misleading when there's already an Earth-1.

So why don't you give it a try? Just, you know... drop all this bait and switch stuff. "Heroes Reborn - A Blackstripe Universe Roleplay", or something. Maybe that's a little narcissistic, I dunno. But it can't be any fun being on the defensive like this all the time, right?